25 December, 2003 Cheaper Is Not Always Better

Some thoughts on used guitars,
beginners, and so on:



     Everyone seems to want a used guitar when they start out, presumably because they wish to save money. Used guitars have been in high demand for the entire 40 years that we've been here. However, you can often get a new guitar for the same price as a used guitar, or even less. This is what's called "supply and demand." The precise value of a used guitar is equal to its cost, plus the cost of the work that it takes to make it as playable as a new guitar. Cheap used guitars are usually hard to play or have uncorrectable defects. That is why they are cheap. Good used guitars can command high prices. In fact, collector activity has driven the price of some models to many times their new prices. Generally, though, you get what you pay for, which is why we don't always have the very cheapest guitars being sold around town. It's also why we sometimes discourage our patrons from trying to salvage that garage sale special, or the guitar from the closet that Uncle George never learned to play. Guitars have a limited lifetime, and are often pretty warped after a few years of neglect.

     McCabe's believes that the more beginners there are who learn to play, the more experienced guitarists there will be (a few years down the road) to buy more expensive instruments. It is in our best interest to create lots of good guitar players. That is why we provide lessons at McCabe's, and why we have a repair shop to make sure all our guitars (and yours) play well. We catch a lot of flak from our teachers if we sell an unplayable instrument to a student. We also have a rental program, and actively encourage beginners to take advantage of it. With any instrument you rent from us, the cost of the first three months can be applied toward purchase. It is the least expensive way to find out if you will be a happy guitarist, and a very good way for us to encourage you to do just that.

     Beginners need better guitars than experienced players, but sadly, they seldom get them. That is often why beginners quit. This is not a trick to get you to buy a better guitar than you need, it's just a fact. An experienced player can mash down the strings on almost any piece of junk and allow for its defects. A beginner has tender fingers, and underdeveloped muscles. An experienced player knows where unwanted buzzes are coming from and can compensate. A beginner is usually prone to string buzz, because he/she is not clear if the cause is bad technique or a bad (or badly adjusted) instrument. It's no fun playing a guitar that buzzes when you don't want it to, and it makes practice less effective if you have to wrestle with your fretboard.

     Obviously, the more practice time you can get in, the quicker you will learn. If you are a novice playing steel strings (ouch!) you will progress at a slower rate than if you are playing nylon strings (wider and softer to the touch AND more room for your fingers). If you start on a twelve string you will probably make no progress at all. Electric guitars can be adjusted to play quite easily, even though they have steel strings, but the strings are still very close together. An optimum choice is probably to play on nylon strings for six months or so, and, if you still want to play a steel string, change over then.

     Learning to play can be difficult and, at times, unrewarding. There is a hump at three months or so. The brain knoweth, but the fingers won't obey. New neuronal connections must grow in your arms and hands. Neurons, however, grow at a fixed rate, just like nails and hair. You can't rush the process. It's not your fault. Just remember that by repeating the same stuff over and over, you are pushing the axons and dendrites to reconnect in new ways. New lines of communication are being formed between your brain and your fingers. Once the new networks are in place, your hands will automatically go to the right position when your mind says "B7 chord, please," and you won't have to think about it again. Just like riding a bicycle, or skiing, or skating, the network that makes it possible will be there for the rest of your life. And then maybe, one day, you'll want to buy a really good, expensive guitar.



BACK TO HOME PAGE